Praeda

Feenix WoW


    Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Share
    avatar
    whydodge
    Newcomer
    Newcomer

    Antal inlägg : 5
    Join date : 2013-07-06

    Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  whydodge on Sat Jul 06, 2013 11:43 pm

    1. Personal Information



    Your name : Toni Eriksson

    Your age :23

    Your nationality :Ukraine/Swede

    Your time zone:Gmt + 1


    Character Information

    Character name : Whydodge

    Class :Warrior

    Race :Human Male

    Spec 3 rend, 2 heroic, 5 tactical ,1 anger management, 2 overpower, 3 deep wounds, 2 impale, 5 cruelty, 5 wrath, 5 BattleShout, 5 enrage, 5 flurry, 2 execute, 4 dual specc , 1 Bloodthirst.

    Tanking one : imageshack.us/photo/my-images/809/edqm.jpg

    Attuned to MC/BWL/Naxxramas : Yes all attunements.

    List all your gear and enchants 12 crit / 9 hit , 6379 hp unbuffed, 8214 armor, str 254, agi 121, stamina 477, T3 head, gauntlets, feet, bracers, t2 shoulders, enchanted thorium chest, spineshatter/bloodlords, elementium reinforced bulwark, plague bearer, Mandokir's sting ,fahrads reloading repeater, onyxia blood talisman, force of will, overlords crimson band, band of the steadfast hero, legplates of vigilance, belt of the sandreaver,Master dragoslayer's medallion. Enchanted with + threat , stamina + idol enchanted helmet, legs stamina +8, wpn agi +15 , shield +7 stam. (turning in next aq40 for ring).

    Resistances ( Fire / Nature / Frost ) :Full set fr / nr /frost , NR gear : Ironvine belt,chest,gloves,(+15NR enchantedgaeas embrace), acid-etched shoulders, ring of binding, crypt stalker leggings, FR gear: Dark iron bracers, peridot circle of fire resistance, dark iron leggins +20 FR enchanted, Dark iron helm +20 FR enchanted, Dark iron gauntlets,Onyxia Scale cloak +15 FR enchanted. + fr pots, FR gear: Ring of binding, icebane bracers, icebane leggings, Icebane gauntlets, Icebane shoulders, ramaldni's ice grasp. All resistance gear is enchanted with either the resistance enchants or stamina.

    Show us your UI imgur.com/W2oK2QQ

    List of the addons you are currently using :!ImprovedErrorFrame,_LazyPig,Ace 1&2, AggroAlert, AnaronsWoWMod, Atlas, Bagnon (All), Bigwigs mesmerize edition, Damagemeters, CCWatch, CT_MailMod,CT_RaidAssist,CThunWarner, EquipCompare,ImproveDressingRoom,KLHThreatMeter, Partyspotter,Sct (CD,KB), Sell value, Special talent, Wardrobe, WIM (<3), Xloot, Xperl,

    PvE Experience : 11/15 as fury, 9/9 aq40. Bwl full clear as tank, mc and raids under, Offtanked somethings in naxxrammas, like faerlina etc. i learn fast

    Previous guilds in Feenix : Envenom, Like a boss.


    General Information

    Are you able to attend to atleast 3 raids, every week (We raid Sun,Tues,Thurs 19:30-23:30 Server Time and invites start at 19.00 ST): Yes

    Can you come to raids and supply your own consumables (e.g. Flasks).Please state what concumables you are using: Yes , titan, mongoose, sharpening(more threat), rumsey, smoked desert dumplings, Giants,Brute force, light rumsey, FR/NR/FRO, + Scrolls / dmf / ony if possible.

    We might have to rotate you during a raid, are you willing to stay on stand by ? Yes i would understand

    Have you read the rules and do you accept them ? Yes i do !

    Is there any member in <Praeda> that can vouch for you ? No i do not think so actually

    Since the forum is a big part of the community you are obligated to be active on the forum and sign up for raids and contribute with your opinions. Are you willing to go along with this: Yes i am Smile

    Zerroc's favourite song ( Must answer ) : Dont understand Razz

    (Optional) Add something you think we find interesting or useful :  I'm a very polite and honest guy, i got a good sense of humor, only time i'm angry ingame is if ppl are slacking intentionally and bringing us others down, else , im a happy person Smile. And 1 more thing, last application i randomly forgot alot of important stuff, i accidentally backpedaled to last page so all that i originally had written were gone (that is a tip, make it so it saves applications in cache memory for atleast 1 minute)
    avatar
    Evileyes
    Master Sergeant
    Master Sergeant

    Antal inlägg : 85
    Join date : 2013-05-22

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  Evileyes on Sun Jul 07, 2013 12:10 am

    Spec:
    Your spec is strange to say the least. Anger management but not 1h spec? I don't see this ever being preferred. 3/3 Imp shield block is useless, should only put 1/3 in it because putting more only increases its duration. And lastly (this is not a must though just my preference) I prefer putting points in Heroic Strike over Sunder Armor because HS is the ability you want to be able to spam all the time. Sunder armor is the one u use when Shield slam/revenge is on cooldown and u have rage for both SA/HS. But as I said, just my preference Smile.

    Gear:
    Gear is fine (A bit weird how you've got half pre raid and half BIS gear o.O Razz). Though I'd like to point out that you should use Bloodlords and not Spineshatter. Spineshatter is way too slow.

    You could just have put the numbers in on how much resistance you have but a quick scan over it and it definitely seems fine.

    Addons:
    Get Tankbuddy it's great Smile

    Experience:
    I see you haven't put Mesmerize in previous guilds, I feel like I remember you being in Mesmerize. Am I wrong? If not why didn't you write it down?

    Consumables:
    I'm a bit surprised you missed very crucial tank consumes like Superior Defense and stamina food? Also Brute Force doesn't stack with Dirge or Giants so it's pretty useless except in very special situations.

    General:
    You say you've read the rules but you don't understand the Zerroc question? Reread the rules and you should understand.


    My opinion:
    With that spec, I'm a bit worried that you don't really have that much knowledge about tanking. Also with your gear being so mixed it gives me the impression you just got carried and didn't pull your own weight =/.

    I'd say +-0 for me, I'm neutral. I'll let one of the pro officers reply with a better opinion :>.

    Good luck!
    avatar
    whydodge
    Newcomer
    Newcomer

    Antal inlägg : 5
    Join date : 2013-07-06

    1

    Post  whydodge on Sun Jul 07, 2013 12:49 am

    1


    Last edited by whydodge on Sun Jul 07, 2013 2:53 pm; edited 1 time in total
    avatar
    Evileyes
    Master Sergeant
    Master Sergeant

    Antal inlägg : 85
    Join date : 2013-05-22

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  Evileyes on Sun Jul 07, 2013 1:15 pm

    whydodge wrote:
    Evileyes wrote:Spec:
    Your spec is strange to say the least. Anger management but not 1h spec? I don't see this ever being preferred. 3/3 Imp shield block is useless, should only put 1/3 in it because putting more only increases its duration. And lastly (this is not a must though just my preference) I prefer putting points in Heroic Strike over Sunder Armor because HS is the ability you want to be able to spam all the time. Sunder armor is the one u use when Shield slam/revenge is on cooldown and u have rage for both SA/HS. But as I said, just my preference Smile.

    Gear:
    Gear is fine (A bit weird how you've got half pre raid and half BIS gear o.O Razz). Though I'd like to point out that you should use Bloodlords and not Spineshatter. Spineshatter is way too slow.

    You could just have put the numbers in on how much resistance you have but a quick scan over it and it definitely seems fine.

    Addons:
    Get Tankbuddy it's great Smile

    Experience:
    I see you haven't put Mesmerize in previous guilds, I feel like I remember you being in Mesmerize. Am I wrong? If not why didn't you write it down?

    Consumables:
    I'm a bit surprised you missed very crucial tank consumes like Superior Defense and stamina food? Also Brute Force doesn't stack with Dirge or Giants so it's pretty useless except in very special situations.

    General:
    You say you've read the rules but you don't understand the Zerroc question? Reread the rules and you should understand.


    My opinion:
    With that spec, I'm a bit worried that you don't really have that much knowledge about tanking. Also with your gear being so mixed it gives me the impression you just got carried and didn't pull your own weight =/.

    I'd say +-0 for me, I'm neutral. I'll let one of the pro officers reply with a better opinion :>.

    Good luck!

    Haha , what the hell? one hand is COMPLETELY useless talent if anything, and i have the same spec as i had b4 core merge, and no i havent been carried at all. i'm mainly dps, maybe that can answer youre question? and no i was just social in it, not a raider, so that does not count. and ofcourse i use superior or lesser defense pots, depending on cashflow, stamina buffs, i always use dirge, i havent slept for 18  hrs now or so, please dont be that narcicistic of you, acting like you got all the answers in the universe Smile. Anger managment has nothing to do with one hand specc, if you want to call hordes best tank for a "newbie" sure go ahead, i even remember him tipping me not to have one handed maxxed out, since u dont get more threat out of it , and a tank is not a dps, and only reason i got 5/5 cruelty is cuz it gives much more threat , crit=threat. i can though debate on the heroic strike option, ive been going through 2 different speccs, one with 3/3 hs . and also the imp shield block, give the user protection for a longer period of time, for example, if you get hit by flurry strikes from adds etc. it protects u longer. its possible to mixture with it, but ive always gone with 3/3 sblock. better safe then sorry.

    First of all, chill with the attitude.

    Second of all, you should not blatantly copy "the best tank on horde side" and think it will work well for you. If he is BIS geared he has a lot more leeway than you do. You are using bloodlords whereas he probably is using widows remorse or TF meaning your threat is much lower than his. Second of all, anger management has everything to do with 1h spec since you've wasted 4 points in anger management that you could have put in 1h spec. Only thing Anger Management would ever be useful for is having a few more rage points leftover between trash, which is completely useless to spec for, if you want to skip 1h at least put those points in Piercing Howl. And yes you do get more threat out of it, not sure what you are on about. Also a tank pushing some useful DPS isn't a bad thing. And I never called anyone a "newbie".

    Going beyond 1/3 in Imp SB is completely wasted. You will never need it to last longer. "Better safe than sorry" doesn't apply when you have a limited amount of points. Not going to go deeper into that since any decent tank will tell you the same thing.

    Changing my opinion to -1 due to extremely bad attitude and proving you don't know much about tanking.
    avatar
    whydodge
    Newcomer
    Newcomer

    Antal inlägg : 5
    Join date : 2013-07-06

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  whydodge on Sun Jul 07, 2013 2:59 pm

    Evileyes wrote:
    whydodge wrote:
    Evileyes wrote:Spec:
    Your spec is strange to say the least. Anger management but not 1h spec? I don't see this ever being preferred. 3/3 Imp shield block is useless, should only put 1/3 in it because putting more only increases its duration. And lastly (this is not a must though just my preference) I prefer putting points in Heroic Strike over Sunder Armor because HS is the ability you want to be able to spam all the time. Sunder armor is the one u use when Shield slam/revenge is on cooldown and u have rage for both SA/HS. But as I said, just my preference Smile.

    Gear:
    Gear is fine (A bit weird how you've got half pre raid and half BIS gear o.O Razz). Though I'd like to point out that you should use Bloodlords and not Spineshatter. Spineshatter is way too slow.

    You could just have put the numbers in on how much resistance you have but a quick scan over it and it definitely seems fine.

    Addons:
    Get Tankbuddy it's great Smile

    Experience:
    I see you haven't put Mesmerize in previous guilds, I feel like I remember you being in Mesmerize. Am I wrong? If not why didn't you write it down?

    Consumables:
    I'm a bit surprised you missed very crucial tank consumes like Superior Defense and stamina food? Also Brute Force doesn't stack with Dirge or Giants so it's pretty useless except in very special situations.

    General:
    You say you've read the rules but you don't understand the Zerroc question? Reread the rules and you should understand.


    My opinion:
    With that spec, I'm a bit worried that you don't really have that much knowledge about tanking. Also with your gear being so mixed it gives me the impression you just got carried and didn't pull your own weight =/.

    I'd say +-0 for me, I'm neutral. I'll let one of the pro officers reply with a better opinion :>.

    Good luck!

    Haha , what the hell? one hand is COMPLETELY useless talent if anything, and i have the same spec as i had b4 core merge, and no i havent been carried at all. i'm mainly dps, maybe that can answer youre question? and no i was just social in it, not a raider, so that does not count. and ofcourse i use superior or lesser defense pots, depending on cashflow, stamina buffs, i always use dirge, i havent slept for 18  hrs now or so, please dont be that narcicistic of you, acting like you got all the answers in the universe Smile. Anger managment has nothing to do with one hand specc, if you want to call hordes best tank for a "newbie" sure go ahead, i even remember him tipping me not to have one handed maxxed out, since u dont get more threat out of it , and a tank is not a dps, and only reason i got 5/5 cruelty is cuz it gives much more threat , crit=threat. i can though debate on the heroic strike option, ive been going through 2 different speccs, one with 3/3 hs . and also the imp shield block, give the user protection for a longer period of time, for example, if you get hit by flurry strikes from adds etc. it protects u longer. its possible to mixture with it, but ive always gone with 3/3 sblock. better safe then sorry.

    First of all, chill with the attitude.

    Second of all, you should not blatantly copy "the best tank on horde side" and think it will work well for you. If he is BIS geared he has a lot more leeway than you do. You are using bloodlords whereas he probably is using widows remorse or TF meaning your threat is much lower than his. Second of all, anger management has everything to do with 1h spec since you've wasted 4 points in anger management that you could have put in 1h spec. Only thing Anger Management would ever be useful for is having a few more rage points leftover between trash, which is completely useless to spec for, if you want to skip 1h at least put those points in Piercing Howl. And yes you do get more threat out of it, not sure what you are on about. Also a tank pushing some useful DPS isn't a bad thing. And I never called anyone a "newbie".

    Going beyond 1/3 in Imp SB is completely wasted. You will never need it to last longer. "Better safe than sorry" doesn't apply when you have a limited amount of points. Not going to go deeper into that since any decent tank will tell you the same thing.

    Changing my opinion to -1 due to extremely bad attitude and proving you don't know much about tanking.



    Umm.. anger management only has 1/1 points, care to explain what you mean? and 1 handed specialisation is only to increase the damage done, i would rather use the talent "iron will" in naxx its pretty good to have that, it may be true i dont have widows or tf yet, but does that i cant hold threat? back in retail ppl had either t1/t2 or full t2 when entering naxx and still did it Smile. and what bad attitude are you referring to? you like started to have preconceptions about my tanking skills without even seen it, and you, yourself doesnt really seem to know about the specc table at all tbh ? your whole point in this referrs to the "anger management having 4 points and claim also that damage done is more important then protection as tank, excuse me for saying so , but you dont seem to think in the ways of tanks usually do, you think like a dps" Thank you , that is all. Smile
    avatar
    Evileyes
    Master Sergeant
    Master Sergeant

    Antal inlägg : 85
    Join date : 2013-05-22

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  Evileyes on Sun Jul 07, 2013 3:21 pm

    whydodge wrote:
    Evileyes wrote:
    whydodge wrote:
    Evileyes wrote:Spec:
    Your spec is strange to say the least. Anger management but not 1h spec? I don't see this ever being preferred. 3/3 Imp shield block is useless, should only put 1/3 in it because putting more only increases its duration. And lastly (this is not a must though just my preference) I prefer putting points in Heroic Strike over Sunder Armor because HS is the ability you want to be able to spam all the time. Sunder armor is the one u use when Shield slam/revenge is on cooldown and u have rage for both SA/HS. But as I said, just my preference Smile.

    Gear:
    Gear is fine (A bit weird how you've got half pre raid and half BIS gear o.O Razz). Though I'd like to point out that you should use Bloodlords and not Spineshatter. Spineshatter is way too slow.

    You could just have put the numbers in on how much resistance you have but a quick scan over it and it definitely seems fine.

    Addons:
    Get Tankbuddy it's great Smile

    Experience:
    I see you haven't put Mesmerize in previous guilds, I feel like I remember you being in Mesmerize. Am I wrong? If not why didn't you write it down?

    Consumables:
    I'm a bit surprised you missed very crucial tank consumes like Superior Defense and stamina food? Also Brute Force doesn't stack with Dirge or Giants so it's pretty useless except in very special situations.

    General:
    You say you've read the rules but you don't understand the Zerroc question? Reread the rules and you should understand.


    My opinion:
    With that spec, I'm a bit worried that you don't really have that much knowledge about tanking. Also with your gear being so mixed it gives me the impression you just got carried and didn't pull your own weight =/.

    I'd say +-0 for me, I'm neutral. I'll let one of the pro officers reply with a better opinion :>.

    Good luck!

    Haha , what the hell? one hand is COMPLETELY useless talent if anything, and i have the same spec as i had b4 core merge, and no i havent been carried at all. i'm mainly dps, maybe that can answer youre question? and no i was just social in it, not a raider, so that does not count. and ofcourse i use superior or lesser defense pots, depending on cashflow, stamina buffs, i always use dirge, i havent slept for 18  hrs now or so, please dont be that narcicistic of you, acting like you got all the answers in the universe Smile. Anger managment has nothing to do with one hand specc, if you want to call hordes best tank for a "newbie" sure go ahead, i even remember him tipping me not to have one handed maxxed out, since u dont get more threat out of it , and a tank is not a dps, and only reason i got 5/5 cruelty is cuz it gives much more threat , crit=threat. i can though debate on the heroic strike option, ive been going through 2 different speccs, one with 3/3 hs . and also the imp shield block, give the user protection for a longer period of time, for example, if you get hit by flurry strikes from adds etc. it protects u longer. its possible to mixture with it, but ive always gone with 3/3 sblock. better safe then sorry.

    First of all, chill with the attitude.

    Second of all, you should not blatantly copy "the best tank on horde side" and think it will work well for you. If he is BIS geared he has a lot more leeway than you do. You are using bloodlords whereas he probably is using widows remorse or TF meaning your threat is much lower than his. Second of all, anger management has everything to do with 1h spec since you've wasted 4 points in anger management that you could have put in 1h spec. Only thing Anger Management would ever be useful for is having a few more rage points leftover between trash, which is completely useless to spec for, if you want to skip 1h at least put those points in Piercing Howl. And yes you do get more threat out of it, not sure what you are on about. Also a tank pushing some useful DPS isn't a bad thing. And I never called anyone a "newbie".

    Going beyond 1/3 in Imp SB is completely wasted. You will never need it to last longer. "Better safe than sorry" doesn't apply when you have a limited amount of points. Not going to go deeper into that since any decent tank will tell you the same thing.

    Changing my opinion to -1 due to extremely bad attitude and proving you don't know much about tanking.



    Umm.. anger management only has 1/1 points, care to explain what you mean? and 1 handed specialisation is only to increase the damage done, i would rather use the talent "iron will" in naxx its pretty good to have that, it may be true i dont have widows or tf yet, but does that i cant hold threat? back in  retail ppl had either t1/t2 or full t2 when entering naxx and still did it Smile. and what bad attitude are you referring to? you like started to have preconceptions about my tanking skills without even seen it, and you, yourself doesnt really seem to know about the specc table at all tbh ? your whole point in this referrs to the "anger management having 4 points and claim also that damage done is more important then protection as tank, excuse me for saying so , but you dont seem to think in the ways of tanks usually do, you think like a dps"  Thank you , that is all. Smile

    You are not counting the 3 wasted points in Tactical Mastery to get Anger Management.

    Increased damage => Increased threat. People in retail had T2 with the correct spec and not a full raid of BIS dps. We have 8/9 T3 DPSers pounding away at the mob, not T1s. I didn't have any "preconceptions", you are the one applying to Preada. You wrote an application and Praeda is supposed to make a judgement call based on the information you have given on whether or not you should be accepted or not - and based on the information you gave us I formed an opinion. And I even said that I don't know you, I didn't know if you got carried or if your application just came off wrong so I didn't -1 or +1 until your reply where you came off as hostile and ignorant.

    And again, I didn't claim "Anger management has 4 points" - however you did waste 3 points before that to unlock it. And no I never said damage done is more important than protection, where have I told you to give up vital protection talents like Anticipation or Shield spec or whatnot for it? If you are thinking of Imp SB, it is useless beyond 1/3. Ask any good tank on this server and he'll tell you the same thing. You are never going to need an extra 1.5 seconds on your shield block.
    avatar
    whydodge
    Newcomer
    Newcomer

    Antal inlägg : 5
    Join date : 2013-07-06

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  whydodge on Sun Jul 07, 2013 3:23 pm

    Evileyes wrote:
    whydodge wrote:
    Evileyes wrote:
    whydodge wrote:
    Evileyes wrote:Spec:
    Your spec is strange to say the least. Anger management but not 1h spec? I don't see this ever being preferred. 3/3 Imp shield block is useless, should only put 1/3 in it because putting more only increases its duration. And lastly (this is not a must though just my preference) I prefer putting points in Heroic Strike over Sunder Armor because HS is the ability you want to be able to spam all the time. Sunder armor is the one u use when Shield slam/revenge is on cooldown and u have rage for both SA/HS. But as I said, just my preference Smile.

    Gear:
    Gear is fine (A bit weird how you've got half pre raid and half BIS gear o.O Razz). Though I'd like to point out that you should use Bloodlords and not Spineshatter. Spineshatter is way too slow.

    You could just have put the numbers in on how much resistance you have but a quick scan over it and it definitely seems fine.

    Addons:
    Get Tankbuddy it's great Smile

    Experience:
    I see you haven't put Mesmerize in previous guilds, I feel like I remember you being in Mesmerize. Am I wrong? If not why didn't you write it down?

    Consumables:
    I'm a bit surprised you missed very crucial tank consumes like Superior Defense and stamina food? Also Brute Force doesn't stack with Dirge or Giants so it's pretty useless except in very special situations.

    General:
    You say you've read the rules but you don't understand the Zerroc question? Reread the rules and you should understand.


    My opinion:
    With that spec, I'm a bit worried that you don't really have that much knowledge about tanking. Also with your gear being so mixed it gives me the impression you just got carried and didn't pull your own weight =/.

    I'd say +-0 for me, I'm neutral. I'll let one of the pro officers reply with a better opinion :>.

    Good luck!

    Haha , what the hell? one hand is COMPLETELY useless talent if anything, and i have the same spec as i had b4 core merge, and no i havent been carried at all. i'm mainly dps, maybe that can answer youre question? and no i was just social in it, not a raider, so that does not count. and ofcourse i use superior or lesser defense pots, depending on cashflow, stamina buffs, i always use dirge, i havent slept for 18  hrs now or so, please dont be that narcicistic of you, acting like you got all the answers in the universe Smile. Anger managment has nothing to do with one hand specc, if you want to call hordes best tank for a "newbie" sure go ahead, i even remember him tipping me not to have one handed maxxed out, since u dont get more threat out of it , and a tank is not a dps, and only reason i got 5/5 cruelty is cuz it gives much more threat , crit=threat. i can though debate on the heroic strike option, ive been going through 2 different speccs, one with 3/3 hs . and also the imp shield block, give the user protection for a longer period of time, for example, if you get hit by flurry strikes from adds etc. it protects u longer. its possible to mixture with it, but ive always gone with 3/3 sblock. better safe then sorry.

    First of all, chill with the attitude.

    Second of all, you should not blatantly copy "the best tank on horde side" and think it will work well for you. If he is BIS geared he has a lot more leeway than you do. You are using bloodlords whereas he probably is using widows remorse or TF meaning your threat is much lower than his. Second of all, anger management has everything to do with 1h spec since you've wasted 4 points in anger management that you could have put in 1h spec. Only thing Anger Management would ever be useful for is having a few more rage points leftover between trash, which is completely useless to spec for, if you want to skip 1h at least put those points in Piercing Howl. And yes you do get more threat out of it, not sure what you are on about. Also a tank pushing some useful DPS isn't a bad thing. And I never called anyone a "newbie".

    Going beyond 1/3 in Imp SB is completely wasted. You will never need it to last longer. "Better safe than sorry" doesn't apply when you have a limited amount of points. Not going to go deeper into that since any decent tank will tell you the same thing.

    Changing my opinion to -1 due to extremely bad attitude and proving you don't know much about tanking.



    Umm.. anger management only has 1/1 points, care to explain what you mean? and 1 handed specialisation is only to increase the damage done, i would rather use the talent "iron will" in naxx its pretty good to have that, it may be true i dont have widows or tf yet, but does that i cant hold threat? back in  retail ppl had either t1/t2 or full t2 when entering naxx and still did it Smile. and what bad attitude are you referring to? you like started to have preconceptions about my tanking skills without even seen it, and you, yourself doesnt really seem to know about the specc table at all tbh ? your whole point in this referrs to the "anger management having 4 points and claim also that damage done is more important then protection as tank, excuse me for saying so , but you dont seem to think in the ways of tanks usually do, you think like a dps"  Thank you , that is all. Smile

    You are not counting the 3 wasted points in Tactical Mastery to get Anger Management.

    Increased damage => Increased threat. People in retail had T2 with the correct spec and not a full raid of BIS dps. We have 8/9 T3 DPSers pounding away at the mob, not T1s. I didn't have any "preconceptions", you are the one applying to Preada. You wrote an application and Praeda is supposed to make a judgement call based on the information you have given on whether or not you should be accepted or not - and based on the information you gave us I formed an opinion. And I even said that I don't know you, I didn't know if you got carried or if your application just came off wrong so I didn't -1 or +1.

    And again, I didn't claim "Anger management has 4 points" - however you did waste 3 points before that to unlock it. And no I never said damage done is more important than protection, where have I told you to give up vital protection talents like Anticipation or Shield spec or whatnot for it? If you are thinking of Imp SB, it is useless beyond 1/3. Ask any good tank on this server and he'll tell you the same thing. You are never going to need an extra 1.5 seconds on your shield block.


    Ah okay, nah i was just talking about like ironwill etc, instead of 1h specialisation.
    avatar
    Kaifolom
    Sergeant
    Sergeant

    Antal inlägg : 74
    Join date : 2013-03-07
    Age : 24
    Location : Russia

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  Kaifolom on Mon Jul 08, 2013 8:12 am

    If someone interested in my opininion - I take a FAT minus. Just talked with one guy about him - its a bad choice. IMO.
    p.s. about guilds - he was in Mesmerize too.
    avatar
    Hammertimez
    Master Sergeant
    Master Sergeant

    Antal inlägg : 83
    Join date : 2013-06-14

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  Hammertimez on Tue Jul 09, 2013 2:40 pm

    Arguing in your own application topic is not the best way to get into the guild xD.
    avatar
    midzit
    Grand Marshal
    Grand Marshal

    Antal inlägg : 646
    Join date : 2012-01-11

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  midzit on Wed Jul 10, 2013 4:58 am

    dont fight make love

    avatar
    budheavy
    Master Sergeant
    Master Sergeant

    Antal inlägg : 82
    Join date : 2012-04-28
    Location : Taiwan

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  budheavy on Wed Jul 10, 2013 5:20 pm

    you've got pretty good gear. plus one for gear. at least you guys are arguing about how to make the raid better, instead of something totally off topic!
    avatar
    whydodge
    Newcomer
    Newcomer

    Antal inlägg : 5
    Join date : 2013-07-06

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  whydodge on Wed Jul 10, 2013 6:21 pm

    budheavy wrote:you've got pretty good gear.  plus one for gear.  at least you guys are arguing about how to make the raid better, instead of something totally off topic!


    Good point! but i stepped over the line Smile and i do apologize to the concerned ppl
    avatar
    Dzevad
    Commander
    Commander

    Antal inlägg : 223
    Join date : 2012-10-20

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  Dzevad on Wed Jul 10, 2013 7:20 pm

    whydodge wrote:Good point! but i stepped over the line :)and i do apologize to the concerned ppl


    Going in the right direction Wink
    avatar
    Dopeey
    King of Gnomes
    King of Gnomes

    Antal inlägg : 975
    Join date : 2011-11-22
    Age : 29
    Location : Athens

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  Dopeey on Thu Jul 11, 2013 11:51 pm

    Good luck in Pure.

    Declined

    Sponsored content

    Re: Warrior - lvl 60 Tank :)

    Post  Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Wed Nov 22, 2017 9:18 am